Magnolia Grandiflora Michel and Sandrine

Grandiflora‘s two magnolia fragrances are the latest in the wave of magnolia scents launched over the past half-year or so (see my review of another noteworthy launch, Zelda, here). Magnolia Grandiflora Michel was created by Michel Roudnitska, and Magnolia Grandiflora Sandrine was created by Sandrine Videault, who was trained in part by Michel’s father, the legendary Edmond Roudnitska.

michel

Magnolia Grandiflora Michel (Michel) is a blooming white magnolia, a luscious exploration of the creamy, sweet, and lemony aspects of the flower. It is a magnolia in bloom, skillfully blended. If not for really searching for them, and for the flowering of ylang ylang trees that are currently surrounding me, I wouldn’t pick out the individual notes in Michel. But since I am looking, I smell distinct notes of lemon, ylang ylang, vanilla, vetiver, and milk.

Roudnitska’s interpretation of magnolia almost perfectly matches how the flower smells, which is impressive. But for me, it doesn’t capture the magical quality of the flower, its size and waxy feeling of its flowers. Magnolias are almost other-worldly, and Michel doesn’t reflect that. It feels too restrained, too sedate.

sandrine

Magnolia Grandiflora Sandrine (Sandrine) is a starched magnolia. If Michel’s interpretation is the fresh flower, Sandrine’s is a bloom that has been picked, sprayed with a copious amount of starch (the smell of starch is actually there), and laid out in a white bathroom. It is one of the more surprising perfumes I’ve smelled. Although I recognize that there is a lot going on structurally—a green-forward, chypre-influenced approach to the scent of magnolia, for example—the end result is so unusual that I find, when wearing it, that I can’t attend to the parts. Sandrine smells, most of all, like an ultra high end version of Ivory soap or wet wipes. It is the kind of scent that reminds me how iconic functional product scents can be, but simultaneously makes me sad that I can’t always appreciate a perfume that smells like one.

While neither of these perfumes lived up to my personal hopes, I have to say that the brand has done a lot of things I like. They launched just two perfumes to start, in pretty bottles with especially pretty labels (in person, they are a beautiful rose gold and moss green respectively, with a subtle sheen that looks very classy).

For a different and more satisfied take on Magnolia Grandiflora Michel and Sandrine, see Denyse’s review on Grain de Musc.

Sandrine Videault has, sadly, passed away. While this particular fragrance is not a favorite with me, I approach it with respect and appreciation for her undoubted talent. My heartfelt condolences go to her family and loved ones.

Images courtesy Fragrantica. Sample obtained at the Grandiflora store. Reviews are never compensated, and posts are never sponsored. See my Media & Disclosure policy for details.

About these ads

10 responses

  1. I also appreciate smaller launches and I’ll try these when/if I get a chance. But they should have followed Bottega Veneta all the way: those bottles look very nice in 50 ml and cute in 30 ml ;)

  2. I can’t cope with soapy perfumes either but they certainly have a fan base. I think you absolutely did handle the Sandrine review in a very even handed way even though it wasn’t for you, so need for concern there.

    I still want to find a big, creamy, white floral in either magnolia, ylang-ylang or frangipani.

  3. Really interested to read your reviews of these, and I think I might like both for different reasons. I am pretty open to all interpretations of the note, from the simple Kenzo Eau de Fleur de Magnolia to the sharper green treatment in Zelda. ;) There was a Jar scent – Jarling? – that reminded me of extremely expensive soap, so the Sandrine one may be similar, albeit with a magnolia twist. Am still very very curious now!

    • I definitely look forward to your opinion of these, being that you are more equal opportunity with your magnolia scents than I. :) I definitely have a specific way that I want for them to smell, so disappointment is inevitable.

  4. Pingback: Happy Anniversary, APB! « another perfume blog

  5. Pingback: Grandiflora Magnolia Grandiflora Michel EDP Perfume Review | EauMG

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,661 other followers

%d bloggers like this: